Skip to content

Rum Milk Punch

The Rum Milk Punch is a light rum creamy cocktail, creamy and sweet on the palate. Shaken and served in a highball glass.

Rum Milk Punch cocktail: creamy amber drink over ice in a highball glass

Flavor profile

Sweet
40 out of 100
Creamy
97 out of 100
Boozy
21 out of 100

How to make a Rum Milk Punch

To make a Rum Milk Punch, shake with ice and strain into a highball glass: 2 oz light rum, 8 oz milk, ¼ oz simple syrup and 1 nutmeg.

You'll need

1 drink

Pairs well with: Simple syrup · All syrups

Instructions

  1. 1

    Add light rum, milk, simple syrup and nutmeg to a cocktail shaker.

  2. 2

    Fill the shaker with ice.

  3. 3

    Shake hard for 10-15 seconds, until the outside is frosty.

  4. 4

    Strain into a highball glass filled with fresh ice cubes.

Why shake? Milk blends in smoothly only with a hard shake.

No simple syrup? Muddle 1 tsp sugar with a splash of water in the shaker until it dissolves, then carry on.

Rum Milk Punch questions

What does a Rum Milk Punch taste like, and is it sweet?

Lightly sweet, not sugary: it's mostly creamy and sweet. It's a light drink at about 6% ABV once mixed.

How much alcohol is in a Rum Milk Punch?

About 6% ABV after mixing with ice, closer to a beer or glass of wine.

What's the difference between a Rum Milk Punch and an Egg Nog #4?

Both use light rum, milk, simple syrup and nutmeg. The Egg Nog #4 uses egg yolk, bourbon, vanilla extract and egg white. The Rum Milk Punch is shaken and served in a highball glass; the Egg Nog #4 is blended and served in a mug.

Should a Rum Milk Punch be shaken or stirred?

Shaken: milk and simple syrup need a hard shake to mix and chill properly.

What glass do you serve a Rum Milk Punch in?

A highball glass.